Recently in environment Category

PFCs.jpg
Continuing an occasional series on product safety issues relating to modern furnishings

A recent study carried out in Denmark and reported in the Oxford journal "Human Reproduction" links infertility in women to PFC levels in their bodies. The study can be downloaded in pdf form at this link. The results have also been quite widely reported, including this report on the BBC news website.

PFCs are "Perfluorinated" compounds, a class of chemicals that were mostly developed in the 1950s and that (initially at least) seemed inert and were valued for their water repellant properties. They found applications in textile treatments such as stain-guard treatments for carpets, upholstery and other textiles as well as fire-resistant finishes.

The problem with PFCs, along with many other classes of hydrophobic (water-repellant) organic molecules is that they are concentrated in the fats in our bodies, and our livers have no way of breaking them down or digesting them. This means that they tend to accumulate over time. The health effects of this accumulation are only just beginning to be investigated.

The new Danish study says that "in recent decades a remarkable decline in fertility rates has been observed in developed countries which can largely be explained by social changes ... but may also be in part due to reduced fecundity". 8% of women in the US for example have made an infertility related medical appointment at some point in the past. The study looked at women who had fertility issues and concluded that many of them had higher levels of PFCs in their bodies and that a causal link exists.

So What To Do?
This study is just the latest in a series over the last decade or so that have cast doubt on the safety of many solvents and treatments used in household products. It is likely that there will be more to come. My personal recommendation is to cut out the use of synthetic materials and treatments containing PFCs where (in most cases) good natural materials are available to do the same job:
  • avoid stain-resistant treatments, including Scotch-Guard and Stain-Guard and similar materials
  • avoid buying items with stain-resistant or fire-resistant finishes
  • avoid synthetic carpeting generally
  • avoid any personal care products with PFCs, "perfluoro", "fluoro", "polyfluoro" and similar sounding ingredients
  • use ceramic, metal, glass, wood and bamboo rather than plastic cooking and serving utensils

There is a general review of PFCs by the Environmental Working Group at this link.
Wangdenwarp.jpg
On Thursday this week I will be giving a talk for the Beijing International Society. The BIS is open to foreign passport holders in Beijing: talks are free for members, but non-members may also attend (one-time fee: 50RMB, please bring your passport since the talk is inside an embassy compound) There are more details about the BIS on their website:
www.beijinginternationalsociety.com

Here is the talk outline from the BIS flyer:

Tibetan Textiles: Reviving Traditional Skills
Illustrated Lecture
By Mr. Chris Buckley
7.30pm, Thursday, 6 November
Embassy of Kuwait
科威特国大使馆
光华路23号

Keweite Dashiguan
23 Guanghua Lu


Throughout its history, Tibet has been largely pastoral, with its herds of yaks, sheep and other animals providing the material for producing a variety of textile products, including blankets, tents, clothing and, of course, carpets.  However, in recent years many of the traditional skills have been lost.

Chris Buckley, working together with the Tibet Artisan Initiative in Lhasa, has spent the past three years working to recover some of the traditional Tibetan natural dyeing methods.  He will talk about Tibet's rich history of textile manufacture (whether in small-scale cottage industries or larger, commercial enterprises), as well as textile uses.  He will also discuss the sometimes unexpected environmental and social issues relating to dye choice and textile manufacture in Lhasa and area.  

Chris Buckley has lived in China since 1995.  He made his first trip to Tibet in 1996, from which time his interest in Tibetan art and culture developed.  He received a PhD in chemistry from Oxford, training which has proved beneficial to his latest researches into traditional dyeing technologies.

Membership desk opens 7.00pm for 7.30 pm lecture

As a chemistry PhD, and one who dislikes breathing/ingesting unknown substances in daily life, this is a topic I have had an interest in for a long time and one that I will come back to from time to time in this blog. It's also an issue that is familiar to China-residents, subjected as we are to poor quality construction materials, solvents and glues on a daily basis, often in our own homes.

So I read with interest the China Daily (the China English language newspaper) article "Excessive Levels of Toxins Found in Apartments" that appeared on 8th October. Here are some extracts:

GUANGZHOU: Researchers have discovered about 70 percent of apartments in Guangdong's provincial capital contained formaldehyde levels exceeding national standards, the Guangzhou daily reported yesterday.

Experts have urged local residents to avoid undertaking extensive home improvements, the newspaper reported. They also urged home-buyers to wait until their new residences pass environmental inspections before moving in

Guangzhou municipal environmental monitoring center official Li Yingwen said most dwellings with indoor pollution were constructed with substandard artificial panels and fiber boards, and poisonous paints. Some leather furniture also emitted formaldehyde. The chemical can irritate the eyes and lungs, and even trigger asthma attacks. Long term exposure has been linked to leukemia. "The more luxurious the apartments are, the more likely they are to be seriously contaminated" Li said. The formaldehyde levels in some recently completed luxury apartments are as high as 0.6mg per sq m - 5 times the national standard.


The finding of formaldehyde indicates that the culprits are synthetic resins, used not only in plastics (phenol-formaldehyde and related types) but also in materials used to treat and bond wood, leather and other seemingly "natural" materials. The study does not say if other volatile organics such as solvents were tested for in the study. It is both good to see that this issue is being monitored here in China, and disturbing that the problem is so widespread.

So what can we do? Here are some top of mind thoughts for those buying, decorating or furnishing homes:
1) use your nose - some of these materials (such as glue solvents) smell strongly, though some (such as formaldehyde) are less easily detected. Don't sign off against any new apartment or repair work unless it smells ok
2) for new apartments, insist on seeing the environmental inspection. At the same time if you are living in an area with poorly developed civic society/ legal system don't rely on it if your nose is telling you something different. In many parts of the world inspection "pass grades" are for sale
3) If you are redecorating, specify international brand paints and other building materials. Ask if glue will be used and where: eliminate it if possible (nails or tacks will often do the same job). Be prepared to hang around on site and inspect materials yourself, unless you can afford a good project manager to supervise on your behalf.
4) Don't bring suspect materials into your home. This includes all types of furnishings (carpets included). You may not be able to do a volatile organic measurement on the thing you are buying, but common sense will tell you a lot: does the item smell strange, glue-y or plasticky? Is it made by a reputable company or is it a cheap item by a manufacturer that you have never heard of?
5) Natural materials are good, but bear in mind that wood, leather, stone and wool are often treated with resin materials, or stuck onto backings that may be poor in quality. Look carefully and check what it is you are buying.
6) If your living environment smells bad, an air filter fitted with a charcoal filter may help, but you will need a big one with a high capacity and to run it 24-7 if you are going to make a meaningful difference. Air circulation (bathroom/kitchen extractor fans, open windows) will also help reduce the concentrations of organics in the air.

285ABabr.jpg
Volatile Organics (VOCs) are coming to be recognised as a key environmental safety issue in the home and in the office. The problem is that our fondness for synthetic materials for furnishings has brought with it organic materials that are used in industrial processing (as solvents and softening agents, or left-overs from the manufacture of polymers). These are slowly released into the air in your home or office.

If this sounds a bit technical and remote, think again. If you have ever experienced a headache caused by lingering paint odor, or a strange smell in your newly renovated home or office, then you have been affected by VOCs in your environment. The bigger issue is that the long term effects of breathing in small organic molecules are not well understood, and problems may lie ahead.

Carpets made from synthetic materials are a particular and recognized source of VOCs. They can come from the synthetic fiber of the carpet itself, or from carpets made of natural fibers that are embedded in a synthetic backing (flip the carpet over and look at it - if it has a mesh with something that looks like glue or latex on it, then you have a synthetic backing).

Some manufacturers of synthetic carpet tiles have recognized the problem and are making creditable efforts to reduce VOCs. An example is the TacTiles product from InterfaceFlor. These kinds of products will significantly improve office environments over time. But for the home owner the real question is why introduce any synthetic carpet materials into the home at all? I believe that a more responsible choice is to use a good quality handmade carpet such as the ones that my company Torana supplies. We use no solvents, glues, resins or volatile organics at all. The only materials that go into our carpets are pure wool, non-toxic dyes ... and the soap and water we use to wash the carpet after weaving. The best way to eliminate something is not to put it in in the first place.

Aside from synthetic materials, for home use skip carpets from sources you don't know or don't trust, that may have used sub-standard dyes, pesticides or solvents in their manufacture. Buy good quality from sources you can rely on.

Read more about these issues on our website.

About this Archive

This page is an archive of recent entries in the environment category.

design is the previous category.

photography is the next category.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.